Where can I find historic building materials in Tampa Bay?

Tampa Bay has several sources for historic materials: architectural salvage yards carry doors, windows, hardware, and fixtures from local demolitions; specialty antique dealers offer curated, often restored pieces; custom millwork shops can match any historic profile; reclaimed lumber dealers stock heart pine, cypress, and other historic species; and window restoration shops repair or replicate period windows. Beyond local sources, the Southeast has extensive salvage networks, and online marketplaces offer specific items. Building relationships with demolition contractors provides early access to quality materials. We maintain a network of trusted suppliers for our restoration projects.

Are reproduction materials acceptable for historic tax credit projects?

Yes, quality reproductions are generally acceptable under the Secretary of the Interior's Standards, which focus on preserving historic character rather than mandating original materials. The key is that new materials must be compatible in design, color, texture, and other visual qualities. For tax credit projects, document why original materials couldn't be repaired or salvaged, and demonstrate that reproductions match the historic character. SHPO reviewers understand that not everything can be salvage—they want to see thoughtful choices that respect the building's period and style. Mix salvage and reproduction strategically for best results.

How much extra should I budget for historic materials?

Historic materials typically cost 1.5-3x more than standard modern equivalents, depending on rarity and condition. Budget 15-25% waste factor for salvage materials—not all pieces will be usable. Windows and millwork are usually the biggest cost premiums. Hardware can range from affordable reproduction ($20-50 per piece) to expensive antique ($200-1,000+ per piece). Reclaimed flooring runs $8-15/SF versus $3-6/SF for new. For a complete historic renovation, materials premiums often add 20-40% to the finish materials budget. However, tax credits (40% federal + state combined) can more than offset the premium.

Can I use modern materials that look historic?

Sometimes, with care. Vinyl windows, fiber cement siding, and similar modern substitutes are generally not appropriate for tax credit projects or where visibility matters. However, modern materials may be acceptable in non-visible locations, for components that were never exposed (like hidden structural elements), or where the original material is no longer available or practical. The key question is: will it look authentic and meet the Standards? Composite materials that accurately replicate historic appearance are increasingly accepted. Always discuss material substitutions with SHPO before proceeding on tax credit projects.

How do I match existing historic materials?

Matching requires careful analysis and sourcing: for millwork, create a template or have profiles drawn, then work with a custom mill shop; for masonry, conduct mortar analysis and source matching brick (salvage from the same era works best); for tile, work with specialty dealers who can match color and size; for flooring, use the same species and similar grain pattern. Color matching is challenging—new materials often look too bright until they age. Consider selective salvage from concealed areas of the same building. Keep samples and document sources for future repairs. A preservation consultant can help with complex matching.

What should I look for when buying salvage materials?

Inspect carefully before purchase: check wood for rot, insect damage, and structural integrity; examine windows for glass condition, joint tightness, and hardware function; test hardware for operation; look for lead paint (assume positive pre-1978); verify dimensions match your needs; assess restoration required versus price; confirm quantity available for matched sets. Ask about provenance—materials from documented buildings have more value. Bring measurements, photos of existing conditions, and samples for comparison. Build relationships with dealers for best service. Have a vehicle suitable for transport or arrange delivery for large items.

Back to Historic Preservation

Sourcing Historic Materials in Tampa Bay

Finding authentic materials for period-accurate restorations. From architectural salvage to custom millwork, we know where to find what your historic home needs.

Discuss Your Restoration Project (813) 420-7561

Historic Material Categories

Common materials needed for Tampa Bay historic restorations.

Category	Common Items	Sources	Solution
Architectural Millwork	Crown molding, baseboards, door/window casings, wainscoting, columns	Salvage yards, custom millwork shops, architectural antique dealers	Custom knife grinding; profile matching services; on-site milling
Windows & Glass	Wood sash windows, wavy glass, leaded glass, stained glass	Specialty restoration shops, salvage, custom fabrication	Restoration rather than replacement; custom sash fabrication
Hardware	Door knobs, hinges, locks, window hardware, cabinet pulls	Architectural antique dealers, online specialists, reproduction suppliers	Mix salvage and quality reproductions; professional restoration
Masonry & Tile	Historic brick, terra cotta, encaustic tile, marble, granite	Salvage from demolitions, specialty tile suppliers, custom fabrication	Mortar analysis; custom tile reproduction; careful color matching
Roofing	Clay tile, slate, copper, historic shingle profiles	Salvage, specialty roofing suppliers, Cuban tile sources	Reserve tiles from other roof areas; blend new with salvage
Lumber & Flooring	Heart pine, cypress, oak flooring, timber beams	Reclaimed lumber dealers, specialty mills, salvage	Reclaimed lumber from other regions; careful grading and matching

Florida-Specific Historic Materials

Materials unique to Florida's building heritage.

Cuban Tile (Roof)

Barrel tiles from Cuba; distinctive red-orange color

Significance: Defines Tampa/Ybor City historic character

Sourcing: Salvage is best; some reproductions available from Spain/Mexico

Challenges: Limited supply; color matching; structural weight

Dade County Pine

Dense, rot-resistant heart pine from South Florida

Significance: Used in many early Tampa structures

Sourcing: Reclaimed from demolitions; limited new supply

Challenges: Extremely hard; requires carbide tooling; expensive

Tabby / Coquina

Shell-based concrete; coquina limestone

Significance: Early Florida construction; found in older structures

Sourcing: Custom mixing for tabby; coquina from specific quarries

Challenges: Matching historic formulas; proper curing; limited expertise

Pecky Cypress

Cypress with distinctive pocket holes from fungus

Significance: Classic Florida interior paneling and exterior

Sourcing: Salvage; specialty lumber dealers; new growth available

Challenges: Grading for structural use; matching pocket density

Mediterranean Tile

Decorative tiles from Spain, Italy, Cuba

Significance: Common in Tampa's Mediterranean Revival buildings

Sourcing: Salvage, specialty tile dealers, custom reproduction

Challenges: Matching patterns; finding quantity; fragility

Where to Find Historic Materials

Types of suppliers and what to expect from each.

Architectural Salvage Yards

$$-$$$

Salvaged materials from local demolitions and renovations

Best For: Doors, windows, hardware, fixtures, millwork

Tip: Build relationships; visit regularly; have measurements ready

Specialty Antique Dealers

$$$-$$$$

Curated architectural antiques, often restored

Best For: High-quality hardware, lighting, fixtures

Tip: Higher prices but often better condition and provenance

Custom Millwork Shops

$$$-$$$$

Custom fabrication matching historic profiles

Best For: Moldings, casings, specialty woodwork

Tip: Provide samples or detailed drawings; expect lead time

Reclaimed Lumber Dealers

$$-$$$

Salvaged and remilled historic lumber

Best For: Heart pine flooring, cypress, timber beams

Tip: Verify species; check for lead paint; plan for waste factor

Window Restoration Shops

$$-$$$

Restore existing or fabricate new period windows

Best For: Wood sash windows, storm windows, weatherstripping

Tip: Restoration often cheaper than custom new; maintain character

Online Marketplaces

$-$$$$

eBay, Etsy, specialty websites for hardware and fixtures

Best For: Specific hardware items, lighting, small components

Tip: Verify dimensions; check return policies; allow shipping time

Cost-Saving Strategies

Getting authentic results within budget.

Prioritize Visible Areas

Use authentic materials where they matter most; reproductions elsewhere

Potential Savings: Can reduce materials cost 30-40%

Restore Before Replace

Repair existing windows, hardware, millwork rather than replacing

Potential Savings: Often 50% less than new materials; better for tax credits

Regional Sourcing

Look beyond Tampa Bay to other Florida markets, Southeast salvage

Potential Savings: Shipping costs less than local scarcity premiums

Demolition Relationships

Connect with demolition contractors for early access to materials

Potential Savings: Best prices; first pick of quality materials

Combination Approach

Mix new reproduction with salvage accents for authentic look

Potential Savings: Balanced budget while maintaining character

Quality & Tax Credit Considerations

Balancing authenticity, quality, and tax credit requirements.

Factor	Guidance	Tax Credit Note
Authenticity vs. Reproduction	Salvage preferred for visible/significant elements; quality reproductions acceptable for less visible areas	Either can work if compatible with historic character; document choices
Condition Assessment	Inspect salvage carefully for hidden damage, lead paint, structural integrity	Damaged materials may still work if properly restored
Quantity Planning	Order 15-25% extra for salvage; some pieces won't be usable	Document salvage sources; keep records for Part 3 application
Species Verification	Confirm wood species before purchase; affects durability and finish	Using wrong species can trigger Standards issues
Lead Paint	Assume pre-1978 materials contain lead; plan for safe handling	Lead abatement costs can be included in QRE

Frequently Asked Questions

Need Historic Materials for Your Project?

FCS has relationships with salvage dealers, specialty suppliers, and craftsmen throughout Tampa Bay and beyond. We'll help you find the authentic materials your historic home deserves.

Start Your Restoration Call (813) 420-7561

Explore Our Services

Historic Restoration Services SHPO Compliance Historic Tax Credits Historic Material Sourcing Schedule a Consultation

Sourcing Historic Materials in Tampa Bay

Historic Material Categories

Florida-Specific Historic Materials

Cuban Tile (Roof)

Dade County Pine

Tabby / Coquina

Pecky Cypress

Mediterranean Tile

Where to Find Historic Materials

Architectural Salvage Yards

Specialty Antique Dealers

Custom Millwork Shops

Reclaimed Lumber Dealers

Window Restoration Shops

Online Marketplaces

Cost-Saving Strategies

Prioritize Visible Areas

Restore Before Replace

Regional Sourcing

Demolition Relationships

Combination Approach

Quality & Tax Credit Considerations

Frequently Asked Questions

Related Historic Preservation Resources

Hyde Park Renovation Guide

Balancing Modern & Historic

Residential Construction

Need Historic Materials for Your Project?

Explore Our Services